Well, I'm no way an auto guru (anybody can figure that out judging my posts here :D ), but Considering it's not a racing car but a family SUV... I'd rather get the one that is intact after the roll than the one that makes flounder out of everybdy inside (I refer to a recent TV show - today tonight as far as I remember), which exposed a lack of a structure in the car roof that gets squeshed on the roll (guess you know what brand were they talking about). P.S. I'm having a final / long testdrive tomorrow - hope I won;t roll it! :D