Autospeed CAI

[shaohaok]

More on Siting Cold Air Intakes

Finding the right spot to breathe in high pressure air

by Julian Edgar

Back in July 2001 we covered how to use a very sensitive pressure switch to find areas of high pressure at the front of the car – locations ideal for a cold-air intake. In this article, which is a revised and expanded version of that original, we take the concept a step further by using an ultra-sensitive pressure gauge to directly measure the high and low air pressures around a moving car.

These days, most people know that placing an exposed air-filter under the bonnet is just asking for the engine to take big breaths of hot air. To avoid that outcome, it's now common to fit a cold air intake and seal it to the airbox.

However, what's generally not realised is that if a positive pressure can be generated in the cold air intake, the engine will perform better again. Actual on-road measurements that we have made "Eliminating Negative Boost - Part 5" have shown that at speed, a good cold air intake can easily have sufficient air pressure within it to completely cancel the flow restriction of the aircleaner. So, even though the effect of ram-air on performance isn't huge, there's a worthwhile gain that can be made.

But getting that pressure build-up in the duct requires that the mouth of the cold air intake be sited in an area of high aerodynamic pressure.

(Note that the mouth of the duct is sited in an area of high aerodynamic pressure, it doesn’t even have to be facing forward - something which has real advantages in stopping the inhalation of insects, pigeons, dust, etc.)

But how do you find these areas of high pressure so good for engine intakes?

Dynamic Pressures

As the car moves forward, air is deflected above, below and to each side of the car. As an example, take the flows occurring along the centreline of a sedan that has a very good drag coefficient (ie it's slippery) like the pictured early Lexus LS400. Some of the air is deflected over the top of the bonnet, passing along the bonnet, flowing up the windscreen, along the roof, down the rear window and then leaving the car's body at the trailing edge of the boot. (To keep the flow attached to the body in the described manner, the car must have gentle changes of angle only - especially from the roof to the rear glass to the bootlid.)

Other air is deflected beneath the car, flowing along an engine under-tray and then getting mixed with the turbulent flows exiting the engine bay (the air going thorough the radiator has to get out somewhere!) and the other turbulence created by the exhaust and suspension, not to mention the spinning wheels.

But back to the front of the car...

At the front there must be a point above which the air goes over the car, and below which the air goes under the car. This is called the stagnation point, and it is here that there will be the greatest pressure developed on the front of the car as it moves forward. This graphic of a Mercedes shows the high-pressure stagnation area in red, lesser high-pressure areas in green, and the low-pressure areas in blue. (They're low pressure areas because the airflow is being accelerated around a curved surface at each of those spots.)

And hey, that's all very well and good - but how do you find where the stagnation point is on your own car? And what if it's impossible to site the intake for a cold air duct there anyway? How do you rank the quality of other potential sites?

The Gauge

It’s possible to directly measure the air pressure at different locations around the car. What’s needed is a very sensitive pressure gauge, eg one reading from 0-1 inch of water. The most widely available gauges of this sort are the superb Magnehelic pressure measuring gauges made by US company, Dwyer.

Inches of Water

Low pressures are often measured in “inches of water”. But what does this mean?

A pressure of (say) two inches of water is that exerted downwards by a water column 2 inches high. One psi is equal to a pressure of 27.69 inches of water.

Vertical manometers, which are measuring instruments that actually use columns of water, can very accurately measure pressures above about 3 inches of water. For example, flowbenches use manometers to measure their testing pressures and airflows. Additionally, inclined manometers (like the one shown here) can be used to measure accurately down to just tenths of an inch of water.

However, the pressures we’re dealing with here are so low that it is hard to measure them with a fluid manometer, especially in a moving car.

Magnehelic gauges are available in a very wide variety of sensitivities, from a full scale of just 0.25 inches of water up to 150+ inches of water. (Note that sometimes the scale is calibrated in kilopascals or other units.) Because Dwyer has been making Magnehelic gauges for what seems like forever (well, at least 35 years, anyway), the gauges very often come up second-hand on the web. In fact, the gauge shown here was bought as New Old Stock (NOS) on eBay for US$25. Alternatively, new gauges are quite reasonably priced from Dwyer and its agents.

The 0-1 inch of water range of this gauge is excellent as it is sensitive enough to measure actual aerodynamic pressures without excessive road speeds being needed.

Testing

The test procedure is simple.

Firstly, buy some small diameter plastic hose that fits tightly over the Magnehelic gauge’s high pressure hose nipple. I bought 4 metres of 5mm clear plastic hose from the local hardware store for 70 cents a metre.

Then, making sure that the mouth of the hose is placed at right-angles to the direction of airflow, place the open end of the hose at the location that you are investigating. Run the other end of the tube back into the cabin, holding the tube in place with pieces of good quality masking tape. (Good quality so you don't harm your car's paint!)

All that you then need to do is to drive the car at constant speed and have an assistant read off the gauge. Once you have measured the pressure at one location, move the hose and repeat the process, making sure that you are doing the same speed each time the measurement is made.

Doing It

Testing was carried out on a 2003 Lexus RX330 SUV. A Magnehelic 0-1 inch of water gauge was used and a road speed of 60 km/h worked well.

Probe Location Measured Pressure

(inches of water at 60 km/h)

Middle of front numberplate

+ 0.55

Front tow-hook blanking plate

+ 0.40

Leading edge of front undertray

+ 0.30

Middle of headlight

+ 0.20

Middle of Lexus badge in grille

+ 0.20

Base of windscreen

+ 0.10

Below front foglight on bumper

+ 0.05 – 0.1

Front wheel arch

- 0.10

Outer edge of headlight

- 0.45

Top of windscreen

- 0.60

This data is presented in order from the highest measured pressure to the lowest.

It can be seen that the numberplate is definitely in the stagnation zone, with a pressure at 60 km/h much higher than any of the other measured pressures. It’s obviously pretty hard to site a cold-air intake duct in the middle of the numberplate, but it can be seen that there’s also relatively high positive pressure at the leading edge of the front undertray – a much easier place to locate the mouth of the duct.

But what about at the base of the windscreen? Since time immemorial, the intake to the cabin ventilation system has been sited here, because this is generally a high-pressure area. It's also common to place the mouth of a cold air intake through into this plenum volume - in fact we've covered one such approach at "Free-Flowing a Miata MX5". But these measurements show that on the RX330, the available pressure – while still being positive – is much lower than can be obtained across the front of the car.

We’ve also seen air intakes placed through to the wheel-arch area, but on the RX330 the pressure in the wheel-arch is actually lower than atmospheric.... which wouldn’t be very helpful for pushing air into the engine!

As is also shown above on the Mercedes graphic, where air wraps around bodily curves, the pressure is low. This can be seen in the fact that at the top of the windscreen and around the outer edge of the RX330’s headlights, the measured pressure was much lower than elsewhere.

Incidentally, the Magnehelic gauge can be configured to measure either high or low pressures by the simple expedient of moving the tube from one sensing port to the other.

As can be seen here, previous testing of a first-generation Lexus LS400 found similar patterns of pressure distribution across the front of the car.

Higher Speeds

Once the location has been found that looks good to site the cold-air intake, testing can be carried out at a variety of speeds. This step is needed in case the pressure distribution across the front of the car changes as other aerodynamic effects occur.

In the case of the Lexus RX330 SUV, the 0-1 inch of water gauge was too sensitive to measure the pressure build-up at a variety of speeds, so this 0 – 150 inches of water gauge was used instead. The chosen measuring point was near to the towhook blanking plate on the front bumper.

The measurement showed that the pressure rose smoothly with speed – from 0.4 inches at 60 km/h, to 3 inches of water at 120 km/, to 10 inches of water at 150 km/h.

Conclusion

It’s easy to make some measurements and so get a clear picture of the aerodynamic pressures acting on the front of the car. Doing so will mean that you can locate the engine intake to make the most of the free power often going to waste. You'll certainly avoid making some of the glaring errors that we occasionally see... like drawing air straight from the wheel arch!

But keep in mind that once you've found the best position for the mouth of the intake, seal it all the way back to the filter. You don't want that precious pressure just dissipating itself in the engine bay....

[Danthuyer]

nice long read there to go over whilst eating my bacon, eggs for breaky :D

so it looks like we will be getting the welder out this weekend hey Shao ??? *lol

[GZE_Bandit]

Thanks for this. Was reading the first page then realised you had to subscribe for that article :(